You make my heart beep
Scientists
are experimenting with robots that will eventually be able to
reproduce, writes Dylan Evans
Thursday
February 14, 2002
The Guardian
Last
week, a bizarre two-year experiment stirred into life at the Magna
Science Centre in Rotherham, south Yorkshire. Before the eyes of
guests, professor Noel Sharkey of Sheffield University let loose a
fleet of robotic predators and observed as they chased their equally
mechanical prey.
Unlike the
prey-bots, which can gather energy from high-powered lamps
by their solar panels, the predators can only replenish their batteries
by sucking the life out of their victims. The artificial vampires do
this by plunging sinister metal fangs into the heart of the smaller but
more nimble prey and stealing their electricity. What makes this
experiment more than just a jazzed-up version of Robot Wars is that
Sharkey's machines are genuinely autonomous.
They take their own decisions
in real time. Human intervention is
reduced still further by allowing the robots' brains to evolve by means
of natural selection. Every so often, the virtual genes that encode the
best robot control systems are used to create a new generation of
predators and prey. The hope is that this process of artificial
evolution will lead to the emergence of complex pack behaviour, similar
to that which natural evolution has produced in species such as wolves
and lions.
The idea
of allowing robots to evolve has given rise to a new but
rapidly expanding field of research known as evolutionary robotics.
Although it shares many of the insights of artificial life, which
pioneered the use of genetic algorithms in the 1970s and 1980s,
evolutionary robotics is distinguished by its insistence on making the
leap from 2D computer-animations to 3D physically embodied machines.
The aim is
to remove the human being from the process of robot
construction, so that robots can eventually reproduce and maintain
themselves without help. In other words, the aim is to create a whole
new species from scratch - a species of organism unlike any that has
appeared on this planet, composed not of cells and DNA, but of metal
and plastic. In the words of Steve Grand, whose groundbreaking computer
game Creatures was among the first pieces of entertainment software to
incorporate the principles of artificial life, the leading scientists
in this field aspire to be nothing less than latter-day Baron
Frankensteins.
But what
is the point of such an endeavour? Researchers argue that
autonomous robots could prove useful in a range of fields, from
clearing landmines to space exploration. But concerns have also been
raised about the potential dangers. Kevin Warwick, professor of
cybernetics at the University of Reading, foresees a time when
intelligent robots may pose a threat to the survival of humanity. For
the time being, however, such warnings seem premature; the robots
professor Warwick put on display during his Royal Institution Christmas
lectures in 2000 inspired more laughter than fear, thanks to their
reassuring tendency to break down.
Yet it is
doubtful that evolutionary robotics will attain its
objectives while it concentrates on the aggressive behaviours that have
dominated both the research and the public imagination.
As long as
scientists focus exclusively on the evolution of robot
predators, and TV coverage of robotics merely panders to our appetite
for new forms of violence, robots will never get very far. Violent
robots may evolve primitive emotions such as anger and fear, but if the
history of life on earth is anything to go by, that will only take them
to a level of complexity approaching that of insects. To evolve the
greater levels of complexity we observe in higher animals such as
ourselves, robots will have to acquire a broader repertoire of
emotional capacities. It will not be enough for them to get scared and
angry; they will need to be able to feel surprise, to experience joy -
and even fall in love.
Before you
dismiss such talk as far-fetched, consider the following
experiment in preparation at the University of Bath. A population of
robots will be divided into two sexes. Each robot will try to reproduce
by mating with others, but unlike the experiments conducted up to now,
these robots will be fussy about who they mate with. The hope is that,
by introducing mate choice into the process, artificial evolution will
be accelerated, just as occurs with natural evolution. The technical
name for this phenomenon is sexual selection, and its fruits are among
the most eye-catching in the natural world - the peacock's tail, the
bower bird's nest, the baboon's bottom.
Perhaps the
most unsettling thing about this development is the
unpredictable nature of the outcome. Sexual selection is notoriously
capricious, picking on very small features almost at random and taking
them to extremes. But even this uncertainty is preferable to the more
frightening predictability of the focus on aggressive robots. Who
knows? Perhaps robosex will lead to the evolution of robots that care
for their human ancestors rather than wishing to destroy them?
This page was last updated: 23 August 2005.
|