Robot wars
Dylan
Evans glimpses technotopia in Robot: The Future of Flesh and Machines
by Rodney A Brooks
Saturday
April 20, 2002
The Guardian
Robot: The Future of Flesh and Machines
Rodney A Brooks
272pp, Penguin, £16.99
It
may appear rather precocious for a field of study that is less than 50
years old to pride itself on having a "classical" form and
"non-classical" variants. Yet this is how those at the cutting edge of
artificial intelligence (AI) describe the theoretical diversity that
currently characterises their discipline. The "classical" form - which
has also been dubbed GOFAI (Good Old Fashioned AI) - subscribed to a
rather idealised view of intelligence as a capacity for abstract
problem-solving. In the 1980s, however, a growing number of researchers
began to promote a different approach, in which more down-to-earth
capacities, such as being able to find your way from A to B without
bumping into things, were also valued.
One
of the pioneers of this new approach to AI was a dynamic Australian
called Rodney Brooks. Brooks is now director of the Artificial
Intelligence Laboratory at MIT, and his papers are regarded by many as
landmarks. Such lofty heights must have seemed rather distant two
decades ago, when Brooks first began to question the tenets of GOFAI.
At that time, his ideas were regarded as distinctly crazy. When Brooks
presented what has since become his most cited paper, at the Second
International Symposium of Robotics Research in 1985, the chair of the
conference whispered to a col league that "this young man" was surely
"throwing away his career".
In
the first few chapters of Robot , Brooks recounts the story of his
journey from young Turk to leading light, intertwined as it is with the
history of the new AI. Brooks has shaped the field in many ways. Not
only has he played a part in many technological developments, from the
Sojourner robot that Nasa sent to Mars to the robotic doll My Real
Baby, but the list of graduate students who have passed through his lab
reads like a roll call of the brightest young stars in contemporary AI.
These chapters are scientific autobiography at its best, brimming with
the excitement of discovery. The rest of the book, however, is
something of a mixed bag, combining elements of futurology with dashes
of science, philosophy and ethics.
The
futurology is, thankfully, somewhat restrained. Wary of the dangers of
speculating about the distant future, Brooks sensibly restricts most of
his predictions to technological developments that are likely to occur
within the next five or 10 years. For many of these machines, there are
already working prototypes. Always sensitive to the practical issues,
Brooks explains why some of the contraptions so frequently envisioned
in science fiction are unlikely to become reality in the near future.
Humanoid robots that can push the vacuum cleaner around for you are,
unfortunately, a long way off. If carpet-cleaning robots do become
widespread, they are much more likely to look like plastic Frisbees
that scuttle around under your feet. Ditto for robots that mow the
lawn.
What
is missing from Brooks's vision of our robotic future is any sense of
the social inequalities that such technological developments are bound
to exacerbate. The only passage in which he discusses the role of the
developing world in his future technotopia presents a horrific vision
of a new kind of sweatshop - one in which armies of workers sit at
computer terminals, operating the robots that do the housework in
affluent American homes.
The
scientific sections are also disappointing, but for a different reason.
Nobody is better placed than Brooks to explain the main ideas
underpinning the new AI, so it is a real shame to find him repeatedly
shying away from the technical details, which are reserved for a short
appendix.
Those
who wish to see Brooks at his best would be better off buying his
previous book, Cambrian Intelligence , which contains eight of his most
brilliant essays. These essays were not written for a popular audience,
and are all the better for that. However, despite the uneven quality of
Robot , it is an enjoyable read, and worth buying for the first few
chapters alone, which give a wonderfully personal insight into the
remarkable paradigm shift that AI is still undergoing.
Dylan
Evans is research officer in evolutionary robotics at Bath University. www.dylan.org.uk
This page was last updated: 25 Feb 2005.
|